Maybe he is great, it's just we have a 19 year old striker, one on long term injury who may or may not stay, one waaay past his best on the way out, a left winger who can maybe play striker, a tall lampost who fills in badly and that's pretty much it. If Ibra signs on, we need at least 1 striker, if not two.
We have at least 5 first team wingers and two back-up at the moment, why another?
We have yet to replace Carrick (great he has another year, but he's 35), we have maybe two left backs and two right backs. Our main goalkeeper is likely to leave.