Unpopular opinions

That wailing bag of cats?

image

1 Like

Couldn’t disagree more. I could probably name tens of bands more overrated than them. Right off the top of my head - Oasis, Showaddywaddy, Bros, The Smiths, Iron Maiden, The Three Degrees, Jesus And Mary Chain, Sham 69, Happy Mondays (Bez was funny though), Cliff Richard …

But there’s almost no objectivity in any of this. I just don’t rate Champagne Supernova or Mistletoe & Wine. I don’t like cauliflower either, or EastEnders, or swirly-patterned carpets. Other people do.

A lot of other musicians claim to have been influenced by The Beatles and a lot have covered their stuff. Name me 10 Oasis covers that have charted.

VB

4 Likes

Most of the Oasis singles pretty much count, I would have thought.

7 Likes

There you go.

Funny, when I used to come down I was always disappointed I hadn’t learned complex ancient instruments (Sitar) revolutionized the recording process or broadcast the concepts of eastern philosophy to an uptight west.

6 Likes

John Lennon was Middle Class I think.

We were wearing Pierre Cardin collarless suits (with flared trousers) well before the Beatle suit came out and the same with the Beatle haircut which was out of date in London, we were back combing our hair a la Rod Stewart.

collarsless

2 Likes

Suites? :unamused:

2 Likes

6 Likes

Sofa so good?

4 Likes

No. Cunts that can’t count deserve ban, you want ban?

1 Like

The Early Beatles were not considered ‘Cool’ by those defining themselves in such terms (Mods) The Action, Pretty Things & the creation, little Stevie Winwood, Georgie Fame, Small Faces et al were all seen as cool but for the most part it was the US R&B acts that were seen as ‘real’ Bobby Bland / Otis etc. The Who and the Stones were both the biggest cash in’s on the rebellious Mod Scene. The Stones Marketing from Andrew L O was pretty cutting at the time " Would you let your daughter marry a Rolling Stone" The Beatles however were rapidly morphing and by of Revolver (1966) they were less molded by management / more exposed to the new movements happening in the USA and they were accomplished performers. They had been gigging intensely since they lived behind a porno screen in Hamburg and possessed the interplay and songwriting strength can only really come from living ‘in’ music…So much so musicians respected them greatly.

3 Likes

They changed apparently when Bod Dylan mentioned that they should write more than ‘moon and June’ songs and thus Norwegian Wood was born.

1 Like

When The Beatles were writing for there teen audience the Stones first album came out. Here is a track. https://youtu.be/rmO1KJdO2EU

You should have taken a bit more.

John Lydon.

1 Like

Not a band.

What about Kraftwerk from 1973-76? Joy Division from 77-80?

Pedant

You rang, Sir?

I think Lydon’s work on the first couple of PiL records is astounding, but he wasn’t alone was he?