This barely deserves to go in DIY, but there isn’t a “Poorly-skilled tinkering and occasional partial-defucktercating” thread, so…
I keep trying to give-up valves. They’re a perpetual pain in my arse - expensive, unreliable, contradictory, vague in data and a swine to test.
They can test fine and then prettily death-sparkle when you put them in-circuit, or they can light-up red-lights all over a tester yet work flawlessly in-circuit, and they can prance gaily from any one state to any other for literally no reason other than you looked at them wrong.
Anyway @chelseadave sent me some 12AU7 / ECC82s to try - four out of six of them came-up NFG on this:
I’ve had it 15 years, it has its limitations, at best it tells you if a tube will kill your kit, or not.
Probably.
Upside is it’s fairly quick and convenient, isn’t deadly in its own right, and doesn’t need a PhD to operate.
Anyway, something seemed off, Dave’s not a mug, and that was too many dead valves to make sense. So I grabbed some known-good ones and tested them - repeatedly. Never the same result twice, and often “DEAD!”. No.
So off me and the Silicon-chip Orange went to the room of wires and hot-pointy things. And apart it came. Trouble with logic chips is they either work, or they don’t. So for all that I spent time eyebaling for obvious fails, remaking and cleaning poorly-done solder joints, checking contacts and clearances, removing debris, &c, &c, the nett result was no-change. Too much SMD on the board for me to devote several days trying to test individual components which are probably fine anyway - 99% certain it’ll be a chip. Oh well… Shame.
So, into The Cupboard of Shame to retrieve this -
… which is 1969’s equivalent of the Orange: a basic valve health-check. It dies fairly regularly - the meter is sketchy and a proper ballache to get out and dismantle, and you need watchmaker’s skills, eyesight and hand-steadiness to sort some of what’s not quite right with it.
Its upside is it’s also fairly easy to use, and is compatible with a lot of quite late valve types (some nu-vistas, 6DJ8s, &c, &c.). It’s also point-point wired, which helps with reliability overall. Discovered today that a couple of switches are not 100%, so I’ll see if I can fettle or replace them next time I have some time, but I did at least get the meter working again.
Ran a few known-quality valves through it - good and dead ones, and all was as it should be, and lo! - Dave’s valves now test as good…
Too late to start rolling 'em, the Eclipse is a hard taskmaster, being German, so that’ll be kill-or-cure…
I’d love to get hold of a late Avo or Hickock in GWO, but with the prices they now fetch, plus the fact they’d be way beyond me to sort out and calibrate, I continue to prevaricate…
Actually, I’d love to just shift the valve-monkey off my back for good, but the bastard fucking things JUST. SOUND. BETTER. …
GODDAMMIT!